A study conducted in Germany found that men with higher IQs are less inclined to traditional values, but the lead author, psychologist and intelligence researcher Maximilian Krolo of Saarland University, said the researchers did not find these differences among women.
from a logical standpoint, conservatism is lacking any kind of sense or logic. I think it’s safe to assume that, in order to follow blindly an idea that crumbles as soon as you critically think about it, you have to lack the ability to critically think.
What I think tho is that it’s empathy what we should link to intelligence (or whatever you want to call the skill set that allows you to question and critizice everything).
Conservatism is a lack of empathy (which comes with a lack of said “intelligence”).
I also believe this, and want to add that conservatism is mostly a combination of ideals based on grievances and a complete lack of critical thinking thinking as well.
deleted by creator
I know plenty of intelligent conservatives, but all them lack empathy for anyone outside their circle.
I don’t think they are intelligent if they are conservative. Conservatism is objectively bad for the collective. Supporting it means, ultimately, hurting the planet even to the point of making it uninhabitable. And if you think that you, with all the money in the world, can survive in a world like that, then you are not very intelligent.
They are selfish, and they might have some skills. But I don’t think they can be called intelligent when they lack the critical thinking skills to question the most basic concepts of conservatism.
Actual conservatism is just as “logical” as libralism / leftism, or whatever you want to call the other side. Old fashioned conservatism is just the idea that traditional ways of doing things are good, so we should be slow in adopting changes.
Modern American conservatism isn’t conservatism. It’s an incoherent philosophy that resists some changes while making a lot of other very radical changes. There’s no plan behind it. Even their “gameplan”, project 2025, is a mess of contradictory ideas. The execution depends on the whims of an idiotic, incurious, and possibly altzheimer-addled man.
Duh
To be liberal requires empathy. A deep understanding of others and their situations and the knowledge that your own personal needs dont always automatically outweigh others.
Empathy requires emotional intelligence.
Its easy to see it in action. Pick a problem and then look at the solutions offered by populist politicians to solve them.
In the UK one of the problems is immigrants arriving on small boats. The populist “solution”? “STOP THE BOATS” shouted far and wide.
How we ask?
And then silence. And when pressed, the likes of Reform offer more soundbites like “use the navy” and “send them back” but without any substance.
Meanwhile Liberal politicians offer actual solutions that are not sound bites, and they won’t work quickly. Things like working with the French to find and arrest the people organising it. Helping to improve facilities in France and the rest of Europe so the UK isn’t seen as somewhere an immigrant needs to travel to.
Basically, intelligent people aren’t fooled by meaningless slogans. Morons aren’t able to understand that deep problems require deep and complex solutions.
It is not just a question of emotional intelligence. As an autistic person, this is really a weak point in my statistics.
I’m simply not stupid enough ti fall for their ideas.
I agree, there are always occasions where things will be different as you demonstrate
To be liberal requires empathy. A deep understanding of others and their situations and the knowledge that your own personal needs dont always automatically outweigh others.
Not strictly necessarily. For me, it comes down to logic, reason, and evidence.
I’m neurodivergent. This means that among some mild cognitive superpowers, I also have some significant weaknesses, such as an inability to understand or even recognize the inner workings of others. Essentially, the first half of your second sentence, above. That simply isn’t in my wheelhouse, no matter how hard I try. It’s analogous to asking a blind person to pick out the colour red.
But I reach the same place - the second half of the second sentence - by using logic and reason and evidence (usually via science) to come to an understanding of what is correct and good and right and how the needs of others simply don’t restrict my own personal needs in any way, and so carry equally as much importance and have all the same ability to be fulfilled without conflict. And because some of these people are disadvantaged or oppressed, it is my duty as a fucking human being to have their back whenever I have a decent opportunity to do so.
deleted by creator
So interesting… to me (I don’t think my brain profile particularly gets in the way of my daily life) what you describe is the prefrontal cortex version of empathy, but empathy nontheless.
Salutations, fellow human :)
Equating left with lib. Love it. Thanks, appropriator.
What a well thought out response, perfectly formulated to start an informed discussion.
Stop sniffing your own farts and don’t look a gift horse in the mouth
Whats the gift here? Do you know the origin of that phrase?
Aaah a feel-good article for leftists.
Plenty of dumb dumbs among us, don’t worry.
There’s a reason universities lean heavily left
I would disagree on the “heavily” unless you accept the US definition of the right-left paradigm.
Also ignore if you mean heavy in population ratio not how far the needle goes.
What university did you go to?
A canadien one.
Highly depends on what university you go to and whether or not you participate in the Greek culture.
whether or not you participate in the Greek culture.
yogurt?
We’re talking about Universities here, not the hundreds of bullshit liberal arts colleges that are just sleep camps for the Learning Annex.
It really doesnt.
Can you elaborate on that?
Do you mean like “greek” college cults, like the alpha beta omega stuff? Or like Greek from the actual country, Greece?
Use your brain. Obviously it’s the Greek clubs. Everyone who replied to my comment doesn’t understand American Greek fraternities/sororities and the terrible culture surrounding them.
Sure, but perhaps take solace that we’re less deliberately hateful and that stupidity isn’t celebrated as it is among the arch conservatives?
Present! I don’t even remember my times tables
I think that political allegiance is often much more about emotions and sociological relations than intellect. Class thinking is more prevalent than we assume nowadays
Aaah a feel-good article for leftists.
Eh. I don’t feel particularly good that I’m surrounded by conservative idiots.
deleted by creator
That’s why they’ve been attacking public schools for decades, and why they push religion in schools.
The kids of the filthy rich go to private schools that teach capitalism the same way they have for generations.
And how to win at it and defend it from democracy
In USA, conservatives are fine with educating the masses, but they want it to be a Christian education.
Which I can tell you is practically worthless, I mean, look at me. Stuffed full of useless Bible knowledge that I can’t discuss in civilized company. I didn’t even learn about critical thinking until my 20s. Blew my mind
As a dog returneth to his vomit, so a fool returneth to his folly. ~Proverbs 26:11
Higher IQ is also associated with higher Critical Thinking Skills, which help you recognize and avoid conservative propaganda.
IQ testing is pseudoscience. It’s one of the preferred methods of the far right to try to differentiate between races for that very reason. Pseudoscience is a lot more malleable for their purposes than the settled science that says race doesn’t exist biologically.
Having a “high IQ” is only proof that you’re good at IQ tests.
Veritasium made a video talking about IQ tests, their validity and so on. https://youtu.be/FkKPsLxgpuY
One of my key takeaways: IQ tests have some validity as a diagnostic tool for asessing cognitive disabilities or illnesses, but they should not be taken as serious and significant as many less informed people seem to do.
For your own privacy, and the privacy of everybody else interacting with you.
When you share a YouTube link, if you don’t remove the
si=ID, anybody that clicks on that link will then be associated with you. It’s one of the tools Google uses to track your internet usage.Thank you!
Veritasium is the puppet of an investment firm.
Your takeaway on IQ is accurate.
Also see it as a tool, I do think that tool has to be adapted to the region to be usefull. A Dutch or French IQ test (not even language related) would not be usefull in Brazil or Namibia. As far as I know to be usefull it needs to be based on local education and living situations.
One of my key takeaways is that it may have some value in aggregate, like this study, but does not tell an individual how smart they are
It’s not completely pseudo-science, as there are a lot of correlations with things like academic success or job performance:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#Social_correlations
Oh yea, so does your zip code.
I think that extreme upper and lower bounds do say something, but few point differences are entirely worthless. Scoring a 70 is rather significant, and 160 probably is too, but 100 vs 90 vs 110? Meaningless.
[H]owever much all this soothes my vanity, and however much I appreciate being vice-president of Mensa, an organization which bases admission to its membership on IQ, I must, in all honesty, maintain that it means nothing.
What, after all, does such an intelligence test measure but those skills that are associated with intelligence by the individuals designing the test? And those individuals are subject to the cultural pressures and prejudices that force a subjective definition of intelligence. […]
The whole thing is a self-perpetuating device. Men in intellectual control of a dominating section of society define themselves as intelligent, then design tests that are a series of clever little doors that can let through only minds like their own, thus giving them more evidence of “intelligence” and more examples of “intelligent people” and therefore more reason to devise additional tests of the same kind. More circular reasoning!
–Isaac Asimov, “Thinking About Thinking,” 1975
deleted by creator
Fuck IQ. Literally political stance is a better measurement of intelligence.
Wait…
I’m bucking the trend
Nah. You might consider yourself as not intelligent (that’s your opinion, I can’t say since I don’t know you), but you have empathy. And it’s that, empathy (or lack of), what we should link to conservatism. I’ll take a dumb but empathetic person over a smart but psychopathic asshole every time.
Hear hear!
I also love self depreciating humour!
I also love self depreciating humour!
It’s not as good as it used to be.
Hey-oh
Options: More conservative or lower IQ
Implication: Option #2
Secondary analysis: Good person
Interaction behavior: Amicable, but simple
Thanks, youre pretty swell yourself :).
I like to say that I am smart enough to know im not :D, but, at least I like progressive policies.
Amicable, but simple

Gorsh
horseshoe axiom tells us this is also true of the far left
the peer reviewed and reproduced lemmy experiment corroborates this theory
Not much reproduction happening here
In before everyone trashes IQ for being racist and pointless.
And I’m not saying it isn’t ethnocentric and a bit arbitrary. But walk around a Mensa meeting and you’ll see things in common.
Mostly that everyone is really socially inept if not outright problematic.
But 90% liberal, yeah.
Mensa is not a good selector. First off it not that high of an IQ requirement, second, they have to want to join Mensa. Real brilliant folks have little interest.
Let’s not pretend that the bright people skip MENSA to join the Federalist Society.
There’s a reason Trump switched parties to run for President, and it wasn’t because he wanted to target the best and brightest. He wanted rubes and he got them.
Isn’t the requirement 130? That’s decently high, no?
Definitely agree that you’re selecting for people who want to show off and take a bit too much pride in their IQ score though if you’re focusing only on MENSA members.
Yeah 130, which is 2 percentile I believe. Smartest one out of 50 people. That is not smart enough to be special, but just enough to be insufferable.
That’s why I’m top of the bell curve, babbyyyyyy
IQ is racist? It think it’s generally accepted that good culturally neutral IQ test don’t exists and you can’t use it to test differences between races. I think the only problem is that some racists don’t understand this and still try.
Are you claiming that anyone who believes in IQ tests is racist, or that specific racist people are using IQ tests, or what?
I’m claiming that racist people look at differences in some standardized IQ tests between western countries and the rest of the world and claim those prove white people have higher IQs while the science understands that IQ tests can’t be used to compare people from different cultures.
I’d be interested to know if the people decrying IQ tests in this thread could accurately describe one.
This is because reality itself has a strong left-leaning bias, and intelligence makes you encounter that a lot more as you interact with reality.
Sure, there are highly intelligent right-wingers, but intelligence only gives you the cognitive tools to discover reality, it doesn’t force you to use them. Just because a person is intelligent doesn’t mean they can’t slide off into wharrderp fantasy land.
Well there are also a lot of rich intelligent conservatives who are only there because it’s the best place from which to exploit everyone else for further gain.
Yep
Plenty of psychopaths and sociopaths amongst them
I think there’s a litany of problems with this assertion.
Firstly the sample size is 150 people, too small for any meaningful conclusion.
Secondly the article doesn’t make any attempt at a causal relationship. Are men with higher IQs more progressive because they have higher IQs? Or is there some other reason.
One hypothesis is simply that students in the 80s and 90s who were more comfortable with STEM work (and IQ tests) were more likely to go on to tertiary academic studies, and we know that there is a causal relationship between academic achievement and progressive politics. Given the era, perhaps women were less likely to follow that path than their male counterparts.
I’m not saying that’s the answer, it’s just an example of how statistical links aren’t always helpful.
Edit: most of what I said is really dumb and wrong!
150 is actually appropriate for this type of study and effect size.
Especially considering it was a longitudinal study that spanned 35 years. Impressive they could maintain that many participants.
Sure we could always use bigger samples but 150 is really good actually.
Secondly.
Causal research is a whole other thing.
Correlation research comes first. Once that’s established , Then causal research.
Causal research is much more different to conduct for social factors like this. Nearly impossible actually.
So don’t be surprised when such research doesn’t exist.
You can’t manipulate someone’s IQ. And you can’t really manipulate their political leaning.
There is no real way to run an experimental study to find out causes.
Best you can do is find more correlations.
and we know that there is a causal relationship between academic achievement and progressive politics
Do we know that? That’s actually a very strong claim, significantly stronger than the OP’s claim of correlation. For a comment about skepticism of statistical links, your rebuttal is more problematic than the original claim.
Do we know that?
Ran across a paper years ago that did confirm this, but laid out various reasons why, including:
- Many courses that employ debate/reports and the weight of proof, especially the humanities, requiring the student to even moderately master bullshit detection and critical thinking in order to pass those classes.
- Higher education being much more of a “melting pot”, putting the student into direct, personal contact of people coming from a wide variety of other backgrounds that they would have normally never interacted with, forcing them to directly confront personal biases and assumptions.
- STEM courses, in particular, being wholly dismissive of opinions and feelings in favour of facts and evidence, thereby setting up a way of interacting with, and evaluating reality, that tends to favour facts and evidence over feelings and emotions.
As the saying goes, your kid didn’t become a “dirty leftist/commie” because they were indoctrinated by their professors. They became one as a reaction to being exposed to the wider world and all of its variety.
But was causality established? That’s a very difficult thing to do. I’d like to read the paper if you can find it.
Because it’s just as plausible that people predisposed to think critically are more likely to both go to college and move left politically in early adulthood.
Oh well, I can’t be right about everything I guess. Happy to be wrong on this.
I mean, I find it interesting that this pattern does not exist among women.
Too bad the article doesn’t actually link the study.
EDIT: Oops, originally just linked to a figure from the document, heh.
Meanwhile, me:
*holding triangle block piece
…and you know what hole that goes in? That’s right, the square hole.
Correlation doesn’t imply causation, you can be a liberal and a dumb dumb, ask me how I know.
i’m more of a dingus
Teacher: “Good job Snot Flickerman, here’s a jar of paste you can eat.”
https://youtu.be/6pDH66X3ClA right?
















