• 0 Posts
  • 112 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2023

help-circle










  • Okay, that took some finding, but I did find the original language in the act. I agree that the “does and mean or” snippet reads bad, but I think it probably does actually mean or. The snippet reads like (not the actual language, just the form)

    In order to qualify, the candidate must have never:

    • killed a man,
    • stolen a car, and
    • beaten his wife.

    It does say “and,” which means technically a candidate who just killed a man is fine, since he didn’t also steal a car and beat his wife. The “and” side is saying that unless you’re guilty of all three things, you’re an eligible candidate. The “or” side is saying any one is disqualifying by intent of the law.

    Here’s the actual text, for clarity:

    (1) the defendant does not have— ‘‘(A) more than 4 criminal history points, excluding any criminal history points resulting from a 1-point offense, as determined under the sentencing guidelines; ‘‘(B) a prior 3-point offense, as determined under the sentencing guidelines; and ‘‘© a prior 2-point violent offense, as determined under the sentencing guidelines;’’

    My read is that saying “must have a 3pt offense and a 2pt offense” is a pretty clear signal of intent for “or.” It’s tough to imagine a scenario where lawmakers intentionally decided to only block people with both types of offense, but not with just one or the other.

    But RAW says and, which is probably why the courts ruled that way.






  • Sure, it’s notionally possible, but churches provide structure and organization for it. For every one secular food pantry there are ten plus run by a church. And if you shut the churches down, it’s not like there are suddenly going to pop up dozens of secular food pantries in their place.

    Church attendance and giving dwarf any other form of charitable donations, and is therefore a hard thing to replace. Most people I know who go to Church regularly are giving 10+% of their income to the church. Of my friends who don’t go to church, I don’t think I know a single one who’s charitable donations for the year top $5k, and for most it’s sub $1k. And I live in a pretty high income area.

    It turns out that having mandated charitable giving leads to higher rates of charitable giving, and this gives these institutions the bankroll necessary to do things like run soup kitchens and shelters.

    The only other source of money for this is the state, which notoriously underfunds and mismanages this type of work, so churches are filling that gap. So the best case scenario, if all the churches close, would be if the state raised everyone’s taxes to get extra funds to offset the loss of that charity. But it turns out that that’s not a politically savvy move. People hate raised taxes, and most hate the poor. And poor people in general don’t vote in numbers big enough to help you win, so you’re not even buying political good will there. So if the churches go away, it’s not like there’s a real backstop that can come fill the gap.



  • Was my initial stance of “never found anything” a hyperbole? Sure. Not much of one though.

    But your stance of “there are a hundred studies saying X for every one saying Y, but because there are a small handful saying Y we shouldn’t rule Y out” probably isn’t the hard scientific truth you think it is. It’s basically the same logic as being anti-vax.

    And much like being anti-vax, it’s examining aspartame in a vacuum, ignoring the fact that it’s an alternative product to something that is factually shown to be more harmful, even in the best case scenario.

    E.g.: Are vapes bad for you? Sure. Are they worse than cigarettes? Absolutely not. So even though the ideal is to probably use neither, I’d much rather somebody vape.

    So this idea that “aspartame has, in a handful of studies (that go against the grain of the majority of studies) sometimes been shown to have negative effects, therefore artificial sweeteners are worse than sugar,” is a braindead take.


  • I usually don’t bother answering a Gish Gallop, but…

    1 - They didn’t complete the study, it was only 13 people with an existing history of mental disorders

    2 - They basically said it’s so within the tolerances that it’s probably just chance, and that regular soda did as bad or worse

    3 - Could only get the abstract, and it says nothing about their findings

    4 - Combines aspartame and acesulfame-K, so it’s hard to tell from the abstract. The methodology doesn’t fill me with a lot of hope for it though.

    5 - Seems to be the same study as 4 (same group of French people, same author), but for cardiovascular disease instead of cancer? Which, yeah, fat people drink diet soda, have heart disease, and get cancer more than thin people. I’m not sold on their methodology

    6 - It’s a rat study. Again, I can’t see anything but the abstract, so it’s hard to say. But any study that doesn’t do a comparative analysis against regular sugar is suspect in my book

    7 - Like 2, this one says that it’s probably just chance in the conclusion.

    And look, if this was some new chemical on the block, maybe I’d agree that it should have some more testing. But it’s aspartame. It’s been being actively studied since 1965. It’s had a lot of negative PR backed by Domino (et al), which has created a huge amount of public concern. And will all of that, the studies still come out a hundred to one that there’s not really any link to anything.

    Yes, you can find studies that say “aspartame scary.” But they’re basically like all the ones you linked above. Dubious. Most even admit they’re dubious (as seen above). And almost none of the ones that push the “scary” rhetoric compare the effects against regular table sugar, which is also heavily linked to increased cancer/heart disease risk. So it’s not even intellectually honest, even when their numbers happen to random out to slightly agreeing with them.