• 0 Posts
  • 12 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle
  • It’s not so much that it’ll go rogue and decide to punish people or that it’s designed to be good for humanity.

    The fact that it’s possible to build a machine that punishes people who didn’t help create it provides an incentive to deliberately try to create that machine in order to avoid its punishment.

    Believers in the basilisk aren’t trying to make ai to benefit humanity, they’re explicitly trying to create an AI that deliberately punishes those who didn’t build it because they fear that, if they don’t, someone else will and it will come for them.

    The part about it being a magical, omnipotent, time traveling, mind torture device is just framing to make the thought experiment clearer. It’s not required for the basilisk to be effective. Even if the punishment is just death and it can’t get to everyone, and only goes off limited information, that’s still motivation enough for some people.

    It is a scary thing, because it’s only silly if everyone thinks it’s silly and all it takes is one mad billionaire (eg. Elon) to build a lesser basilisk that can cause real harm.



  • There’s a bit of a difference between FLDS style polygamy and modern polyamory.

    Polygamy is about being married to multiple people, but to most people generally refers to situations where men have multiple wives. A “polygamous sect” in Utah generally means a man who is worshipped in a cult-like situation by a group of oppressed women. The wives are groomed through the religion from a very young age to believe that their path to heaven lies in obeying their husband who is closer to god. They’re taught that it’s sinful to think “sinful thoughts” or to question anything their husband says.

    In this case he, quite literally, told them all he was god’s prophet, the successor to Warren Jeffs, the equivalent of Jesus, and his followers needed to stop thinking and live in worship, give him their daughters to be his wives, give him their money and work for him, let him control every aspect of their lives and thank him for the beautiful opportunity to be allowed to worship a real prophet and be one of god’s chosen.

    Not the first time this has happened and not the only active polygamous sect around there. It’s super fucked up even without the child sex offenses.

    On the other hand polyamory is generally about ethical non-monogamy and involves people having multiple loving relationships (married or not). One of the reasons the term was invented (aside from removing the connotations of polygyny and marriage) was to distance polyamorous people from the FLDS which was often the only kind of non-monogamy that people knew about.


  • While this advice is true for all models, when it comes to agentic tasks (add this small feature/write this test harness/find bugs/suggest improvements), open source models are still way behind, vibe code or not.

    Claude Fable or even Opus in an editor like Zed have a 1 million token context window and will “think” through the goals of the application, test their changes, work through debugging processes the way a programmer would, stop to ask for clarification, check diagnostic tools and linters, prompt to run test code, etc.

    Llama, Gemma and Qwen etc. Do lack a lot of the world knowledge to get the goals of the application, but they also just don’t have the debugging skills, won’t test their code, don’t always tool call correctly, get confused as the context increases and nobody has enough vram to run on large context sizes locally.

    They can do autocomplete on small functions but aren’t really there for more complex tasks.

    On top of that, the biggest problem is that the best open source models are trained and released by the same giant tech conglomerates that have an interest in not competing with their own products. Qwen is Alibaba, Llama is Meta, gpt-oss is OpenAI. Even the more “independent” ones, kimi (Moonshot) and GLM (z.ai) are mostly funded by Alibaba and Tencent. They’re released for research and marketing purposes and to please their corporate backers with inflated stock. Almost nobody has the resources to train new models from scratch. People make lots of merges and fine tunes but AI is not democratised the way that traditional programming tools have been.

    Maybe some day there will be enough cheap compute for open source communities to pool together resources to build competing models but they’re not really there yet :(


  • There are quite a few. The best ones are sustainable closed loop datacenters with on-site solar which is becoming pretty common across the world, especially for new builds. Often producing more power than they need and feeding it back to the grid (especially if the local government has an energy buy back scheme).

    But most data centers are pretty tiny and just built into an office building with a bunch of server racks.

    Depending on where you live, a quick web search for data centers in your local area will probably show up dozens of them of varying quality hosting people’s websites and business apps etc. They aren’t any scarier than anything else you find in a city. They’re critical infrastructure that helps make the internet a thing. In most cases, if it wasn’t a datacenter, it would be a car yard or a factory, etc.

    But! There are also truly evil datacenters. Like this insane Utah monstrosity built for a shitty purpose and the size of a freaking city. An obscene monument to the US tech cesspool’s hubris.



  • That’s fair. The nuance that people lose is more that people are often painting them all with the same brush. Protesting any datacenter regardless of impact.

    It becomes something like: “datacenters are evil and are a symbol of techno fascist distopia! If they build a datacenter in my city, the taps will run dry and Elon Musk will use it to make ai porn of my children!” Even if it’s a small solar powered closed loop that provides VPS, storage and web hosting for nerds and small businesses.

    I also do think there’s also a scale of evil there. Some environmental impacts are not immediately obvious and might not be known about during planning. Some were built a long time ago with older tech and are a bit shitty but have a plan to transition to be more sustainable, etc.

    The world is full of “alright but a little bit shit.” It’s not all perfect angels and mustache twirling villains.

    I don’t want to detract too much from the real villains though. Nobody needs a 9GW datacity for military ai.


  • Not all data centres are evil and the issue is nuanced. This one sounds pretty evil though.

    9GW is totally insane and they’re building a gas plant for it instead of renewables (although there’s some solar too). It’s closed loop so the water use fears once it’s running are probably a bit overblown, but the construction itself is going to be ecologically insane. The thing is basically a data city, 162 square km is even larger than a lot of cities and involves building an entire power plant and new energy infrastructure. Building it is a full megaproject and even just noise pollution and the construction impacts will mess with bird migration etc. Obviously the whole thing isn’t going to be full of data centre, some of that space is empty but still.

    It’s also going to have the US military as a major client so… Pretty high up there on the evil scale IMO.


  • They do use emojis quite a lot.

    I think Claude code is the one that does emojis in lists and as icons/graphics the most. Especially in “make me a shitty website/blog” kind of cases. They can’t reliably produce good icons and glyphs yet, so they stick in emojis like graphical placeholders everywhere. Especially in lists.

    You also see it in some of the more corporate, venture capital or ai-friendly github readme.md files so some people see emojis in lists and have an immediate negative response. It’s not universal and the style obviously originated with humans or the AIs wouldn’t have learned it.


  • For the unprivileged container thing, containers tend to be lighter on resources than VMs at the cost of a little isolation (they share the same kernel as proxmox which could have security implications).

    The ability for lxc containers to run unprivileged with all the restrictions that entails alleviates a bit of that security risk.

    Both options are generally considered pretty secure but bugs/vulnerabilities could break isolation in either case. The only real 100% safe isolation is bare metal.

    I tend to run containers unless I have a really good reason to need a VM, and run unprivileged unless I have a really really good reason not to.


  • My recommendation is a VPN server to connect in from outside and have the default gateway for the VPN clients be a server that acts as a router that’s set up with your commercial VPN.

    That way, you can be outside on a phone or a computer, access your internal network and still have your public internet traffic go out through your commercial VPN without having to be able to configure multiple VPN connections at once (eg. Android doesn’t support that).

    Eg. 2 debian proxmox containers. One that runs wireguard (head/tailscale might also work here?) for external access and one that runs mullvad(or whoever) VPN cli and IP forwarding to be the gateway for your clients.

    Only downside is the extra hops to send everything through your home network first rather than straight to the commercial vpn which is probably fine depending on your speeds. You can always disconnect and connect directly to the commercial VPN for faster internet traffic if you need to.