• 1 Post
  • 47 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 27th, 2025

help-circle

  • This is such a keyboard warrior moment here with so little brain cells involved in the actual reasoning, and I can see that you’re clearly trying to make use of the general anti-separatist sentiment here in Canada to rile people up that I find it almost pointless to reply to you. If you think that by simply listing some legitimate sources, you’d have the upper hand in an argument, you’d be dead wrong.

    First off, while i certainly oppose Alberta’s separating from Canada, if they make a legit case to show that the majority of their citizens are in support of that, I don’t see why they can’t just separate. Heck, any province can do that if they want to through legitimate means. Let’s freaking talk about it.

    Secondly, The Rule of Law is important, but it is not absolute. The Law has many limits, and heck, it even changes over time. Nothing that changes over time can be absolute; that’s just contradictory.

    Further, the Rule OF Law is something that is implemented, and good lawyers are trained to understand and uphold the “spirit” of the law, not the exact stipulations of it, which often leaves a lot of details unspecified or vague. And the Law isn’t always updated in a timely manner to answer every complication or conflict in human society; that is practically impossible and untenable. In the case of China and Taiwan, let’s say I forgive you to have very conveniently acknowledged the PRC as the sole owner of the name “China” while ignoring the ROC’s claim over the name, and thus conveniently claiming that Taiwan should simply be treated as the land that the PRC has sovereigty over. The argument over who should be the legitimate receipient of the benefits from the aigned signed Treaty of San Francisco is irrelevant due to the civil war that’s happened in China later on. Both parties are technically, or should I say, legally, at war with each other ever since. And if you really want to argue about that one dumb treated, well, there the damn Treaty of San Francisco itself doesn’t legitimize either the PRC or ROC as the government of China. So bringing this up is moot, and, frankly, it just tells me what contents you’ve been fed with.

    Now onto the where the limits of the law comes in. If we simply follow the letters of the law, oh boy do we have some fun situations that’d happen. So many darn countries would simply not exist if we simply follow it to the letter. France could’ve forever denied having signed a treaty with England to easily legitimate the UK as we know it, or, back in those days, apply enough pressure militarily and economically to the England to supress its people’s desires to declare their own independence. This is what we see today with China; the people of Taiwan has repeatedly showed a desire to declare their own independence from the war, only to be threatened by China with military and economic force. While the Law certainly isn’t under China’s control, if we simply go by your wat of following the law to the dot, then you are simply ruling BY Law while claiming that this is the Rule OF Law, while simultaneously acknowleging thar it’s totally fine and legitimate for stronger countries to strongarm weaker countries into capitulation and submission, all while putting their own claim on “following the law”. If you do not understand what’s so messed up here, I have nothing else to say to you.

    The Rule OF Law is and should always be upheld with discretion, with a good understanding of its spirit instead of its letters, because its absolutism is only probably relevant for its time and not guaranteed to be timeless, unless the human society is held in stasis. Otherwise, and idk if you’ve even come to notice, it’s very easily for interested parties to overwhelm the meaning of the law and uphold them in their own fashion, and thus Rule BY Law.

    And finally, to your last 2 paragraphs, I’d say hold your fucking horses right there. Nobody is convincing civilians to be up in arms and fight in another nation here in Canada. IDK where you’re even getting that from, and you seem so far radicalized that you appear to be rather extreme in how you even comprehend and interpret things. We’re talking about Japan re-arming themselves to fight for Taiwan here, and I am in no way encouraging the Japanese to do so. What I am doing is to sympathize with their situation and understand why they think that this is their way to ensure their own survival. I don’t care who the fuck you are, which country you’re from, or what your beliefs are, but if you can’t look at the situation that Japan is in and tell me they aren’t doing this for self protection, for a country that has literally given up arms for almost 80 fucking years, you either need to grow up and understand human politics, or you’re a naive tool for the CCP.

    If you’re just here to be a tool, then I have wasted my breath on you, but I hope this message would still somehow make some sense to you, or to someone else. Peace out.



  • The riches that the Taiwanese have made are only part of the reason China wants the land. It’s a strategic position for China to take control of along the chain of islands that block their access to the Pacific, all of which are currently friendly to the US. It would allow them to further encircle Japan and South Korea, two countries that house large US military bases, and give them an upper hand in talks as they can easily blockade shipments going to the two countries, and both Japan and SK rely quite a bit on oil tankers coming from the South China Sea for their energy needs. This is why Japan has been super nervous about the recent developments related to Taiwan, not just because of a clear weakening in the will of the US to defend its allies.








  • This is going absolutely nowhere. I don’t know why you’re thinking that I think the current system is better. I’ve said that I don’t believe so. What I’m also saying is that I don’t believe that governments can make sure that we won’t be on the streets either.

    And you’re throwing away my arguments and conveniently forgetting about them and essentially putting me up as some kind of convenient strawman for whatever you’re trying to say. Why wouldn’t a government kick a bunch of people out so that they can build that resort for people that they know would vote for them? A “large illegal immigrant population” is simply a convenient target down south for the fascists Republicunts to channel national anger at so that the people would vote for them. While Canada isn’t as polarized as the States is, and racial tensions aren’t as high, it does exist and isn’t something to dismiss, and given the right events, it could fan the flames. And it doesn’t have to be racial. It can be on nationalistic lines, and I can guarantee you that that sentiment is definitely on the rise.


  • I get it. The grocery businesses and telco business that we know of exist and are local players. That has more to say about our policies for businesses, that it allows for oligopolies to fester, but it’s a weak reason to go to the extent of full nationalization imo. IMO government should not allow a singular group of people to fully control almost every facet of an industry. But governments should not have the power to stamp out its own competitors, lest it becomes the very thing we don’t like seeing now in these private companies.

    And while those are examples, there are also some that’s for the other side. While not a national company, the TTC is one such example at the city + provincial level: service degradation has continued on, disruptions have become increasingly frequent, the Eglinton Crosstown is still under construction after more than 10 years (though the private sector is also to blame on this end), Line 6 is only finally here after 10+ years as well, and even with these two lines, Toronto is nowhere near the level of accessibility you’d expect of a city it’s size outside of downtown core, and it literally hasn’t changed much for the last 100 years. While the TTC isn’t to be fully blamed for these woes (because of car-centric developments that have taken over the national psyche), if you listen to transit advocates talk about the TTC, you’ll hear a lot of frustrating episodes, e.g. having outdated, error-prone rail infrastructure and repeatedly refusing to upgrade them.

    And then there’s Canada Post with all its episodes, sagas even, in recent years. They’ve repeatedly refused to both improve services and pay better wages, even as the CUPW continually suggested to the management to better use their abilities.

    I think this should tell us that you can’t rely on either nationalization or privatization alone. Either way has a possibility of slipping into stagnation once they’ve reached some kind of steady state.


  • If you’re running an infrastructure that many need, you could just say no to abusers, just like a healthy business would do.

    And I know the times we’re in, but it’s just so odd to assume that businesses that serve the country are all owned and controlled by foreign companies. Why can’t a local player be in that place?

    Public alternatives are fine, but they’ve generally stagnated in terms of improving their services and offerings, because, and I absolutely hate that I agree with the capitalists here even though I’m looking at it differently, at some point in their lifetime, the stability that a government-funded company offers will attract people who seek that stability without understanding how to achieve long term stability (which is to constantly improvement, instead of preserving the status quo). Income for these companies eventually drop, and we end up having to keep them afloat with tax money. That’s not necessarily a bad thing cause not all public services need to be profitable, but it’s still desirable to have them fund most of their activities on their own.

    For cloud, it’s why mentioned that the government should be as removed as possible from its operations. These sorts of services can easily contain a lot of sensitive information, and the government should be kept at a healthy gap away from that data. Government-funded, yes, but let there also be a more direct mechanism from more grassroots and local organizations as well.



  • I see a lot of comments are proposing for the nationalization of whole industries, which is somewhat concerning. There needs to be some balance, not to fatten the checks of those billionaires, and not to make the government too powerful.

    For example, instead of (re-)nationalizing CN, nationalize the tracks themselves. The government can lay down tracks for places that need to be reached, and companies can then run their trains on them. It’s no different from how roads are public really. Companies can then focus on serving section of the tracks for areas that they understand best. Of course, there will be cases where there’s a need to consider if the investment from the government is worth it, cause what if they laid the tracks but no one’s willing to take advantage of that? Well, they can let companies bid, and there’s no bidder, they can choose to not take on the project. Of course, there’s always the option for the government to have its own train company to serve certain areas.

    For telcos, instead of nationalizing the entire vertical, nationalize cell towers and cable paths. Allow companies to build their own towers if they so desire, but the main draw is that different providers can rely on shared infrastructure, and none of this Robelus bullshit that we have right now. Cable paths is probably odd, but these sorts of technology get changed quite often. The government can still own some cables, allowing smaller players to take advantage of those, but it would level out the playing field by a lot.

    For the Internet and whole businesses within it, having our own cloud infrastructure, or AWS alternative, would be best. People can then run whatever on those. There is, of course, a concern of the government not respecting people’s privacies, and so it needs to be run somewhat independent of the government, allowing the government to set directions but not what exactly to do; sort of Crown-corp-y if you will.

    In all my examples, the idea is simply this: nationalize the stuff that serve as the basis for a particular service. Think roads instead of cars.


  • Oh you know that people will vote for Nazi’s on a long enough timescale. The fact that we have fascists becoming governments around the world right now, and the fact that there’s some far right multinational organization working on all sorts of disinformation campaigns around the world, is already showing us the limits of democracy: if there’s a large enough group of people with that will (however small they are relative to the whole population), they will exercise everything they can to get into power; start small, underfund education and public welfare, create the environment for public anger, and then feed on that anger to make themselves government.

    Anytime anyone tells me that “the people have decided”, I wince, cause people can be gullible, simply overwhelmed by (dis)information or just keeping themselves afloat, be pressured into following suit, etc. Democracy relies on the fact that people can be rational at the voting ballot, but that basis is being undermined.

    And sorry, but you’ve misread that paragraph and sentence that you quoted, mostly cause of my wording (now that I look at that), and I apologize for that. I said that in the context of an anarchic society, not our current one.


  • I’m not promoting private ownership of land, but I fail just fail to see how allowing a single entity to manage land would be better than a more decentralized one. Having one dickhead who owns some land trying to gouge others is bad, but we can go somewhere else. If instead, we have THE dickhead who “owns” ALL of the land trying to gouge groups of people they specifically don’t like (oh you know that those racists and neo-Nazi’s will try to get into government), then where the hell are people supposed to go?

    Sure, there may be a handful of landlords who own a lot of land and it’s hard to avoid them, but that’s more telling of an oligarchic society and its problems, and not that private ownership is a problem.

    Some of those examples from history weren’t great. If anything, they (aside from the tribal ownership of land) more-so exemplify things that seem to frustrate you: few people own the lands and they’ve dickheads about it, but we are left with no choice.

    And just because it never happened in the past, doesn’t mean that it’s bad. Personal property isn’t private property. You can use a piece of land how you wish, but you don’t own it forever: you can use it as long as you’re still using it for your personal needs. This “you” can expand into a group, eg a family, and as long as this group still continues to use it directly, it’s “theirs”. No small private group of people can “own” a piece of land and demand those on it to pay for it.

    As for saying that tracking private ownership of land is bureaucratic, that doesn’t sound too different from how it’s inherently bureaucratic that the government owns it all.


  • AFAIK, the author isn’t anti-proprietary. His goal with the newsletter is to share news that relates to self-hosting, which isn’t limited to FOSS, which is something he mentioned in one of his recent newsletters (it’s a common criticism he gets apparently). And there’s the reality where the vast majority of the source for selfhosted software are hosted on Github.



  • I don’t think that really answers the question and feels like a nothing burger. There would be no land appreciation when it’s all owned by the government. Its value is purely perceived and never realized in such a scenario.

    And to be fair, land is somewhat of an interesting case. Suppose you own a piece of land and have no debtors, but you’ve died without descendants or relatives, and certainly without a will, wouldn’t the government just take over that? In essence, the government has a holding on the land, and you’re holding an indefinite lease that can be transferred. Expropriation is simply a mechanism for the government to take back the lease, but they are still obligated to pay to owners. To the owners, it sucks, cause you might really like the piece of land, or that your livelihood depends on it. Hence the conversation should be about fair compensation or equivalent exchange, and a strong scrutiny of expropriation (provably worthy investments being done by the government).

    That said, that does depend on your political beliefs on individual freedom. I believe that we should have the freedom to be where we want and do what we want, but to the extent where it doesn’t cause others pain, discomfort, or jeopardy of any sorts (physical, mental, societal where appropriate), or when there is something that would benefit us, collectively. Being asked to move, and being paid fairly to do so, is annoying and disruptive, but if all we do is reject every attempt of improving public spaces and infrastructure projects, then I think we have a more serious problem than just land ownership.

    Of course, every case of expropriation should be fully scrutinized. Do these people HAVE to move? There are many ways to incorporate existing infrastructure with new ones.

    I simply don’t believe or trust that governments will forever be benign, and full ownership of land by only the government is no different from the age of kings: all it takes is one bad king to ruin it all.

    Even in an anarchic society, there’s still a sense of ownership of space: this is where I can be alone by myself, and that my right to privacy in my space is respected.