This doesn’t have anything to do with progressive politics, is overly lengthy 🚩and I have no idea what you are trying to tell.
What is progressive politics to you?
Freedom for all.
This is just Israel bad or something. It is so lengthy that it isn’t worth the read or tokens to summarize. In my experience only conspiracy nut jobs write like that.
I’m sorry, what? This is an article about a book written by a socialist writer, about a historic socialist organization, published in a socialist website. And you’re basing your entire judgement of this book review on its …length? That’s kind of silly, don’t you think?
Janey Stone: At a time like this, we need more than ever books that rediscover the other Jewish tradition, the history of radical struggle, opposition to Zionism, and socialism.
This is the sole reason Janey reviewed Here Where We Live Is Our Country (2026).
tokens to summarize
I believe thou has been too much dependent on a lousy machine. Time to refund those tokens. It’s only 56 short paragraphs. I read that in 5minutes.
You realize that that is a very tall ask? People barely read headlines on here and op didn’t give any context or hint that it may be someone of repute.
wait, are you saying you can’t even read the title acargitz copy&pasted? Because it’s extremely clear what the review’s point is, by the headline alone. If you can’t read 8 words, I think you may need to visit a doctor.
deleted by creator
Ah. forgiven:
bund (n): 1) A league or confederacy; especially the confederation of German states.
2) A group of foreign sympathizers of Nazi Germany, most notoriously before and during World War II.
Etymology: From German Bund (“alliance, league”). Doublet of Bund, bond and band.Zionism[a] is an ethnic nationalist movement that emerged in late 19th-century Europe to establish and support a Jewish homeland through colonization in the region of Palestine,[1]
Jewish (adj.): 1) Following the religion of Judaism. [1540s[1]]
2) Of or relating to Jews, their ethnicities or cultures.
I don’t know what the bund is and the rest is generic mumbo jumbo that can range from jew bad to legitimate criticism.
4¶: The General Jewish Labour Bund in Lithuania, Poland, and Russia, generally known as the Jewish Labor Bund or just simply the Bund, was founded in 1897 in Vilna (Vilnius, now in Lithuania) in the tsarist empire. It is one of the most important but least recognized socialist organizations in Europe.
Ahem. If you don’t know what the General Jewish Labour Bund was, there is a very good new book that is all about it, it’s a New York Times Bestseller, too:
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Here_Where_We_Live_Is_Our_Country
- https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/646320/here-where-we-live-is-our-country-by-molly-crabapple/
Oh, and if you want to read a book review about that book, there is a pretty lengthy one linked at the top.
Trust me, this is far from “jews bad”. Quite the opposite actually.
Bund is a jewish organization that is anti zionist . You are accusing some jews to be antisemitic?
you could have easily had no opinion because you didn’t read it. that would have cost you nothing. tokens or otherwise. but you have an ax to grind to protect zionism, it’s just too bad you are too lazy to bring up a coherent argument. not that i envy your position on genocide, that’s very hard to argue.
If I wanted to protect Zionism staying silent would have been the best course of action.
then why do you have an opinion over something you did not read, and are for some reason proud of not reading, and have made multiple responses denouncing said thing you did not read? you are so unread that you don’t even know what position you are taking in the topic? the time you spent here has more then eclipsed the time it would have taken to just read the material.
Israel is evil. Fuck you
This is so idiotic. Nothing more progressive than supporting anti colonial and anti supremacist ideologies and opposing colonial and supermasist ideology
“colonial” Israel. An ottoman subject sure sounds like a Western colony. Sure. They do a bunch of bad shit, but their history isn’t typical colonial history.
Other empires colonized the land therefore the zionazis can too?
Calling the ottomans a colonizer? Did the Chinese colonize Beijing?
Israel is colonizing Palestinians and you are ok with it. I am not falling into your deflection
Typical book definitions of colonialism don’t exactly fit what Israel is doing. Calling it genocide may be more fitting.
A bunch of Europeans came to the land and expulsed Palestinians for there land to create a state then till today they still colonizing the west bank and constantly grow the number the colonizers and colonies there





