cross-posted from: https://fedia.io/m/gaming@beehaw.org/t/3751309
The Stop Killing Games campaign have revealed their support for a Californian bill related to game server shoutdowns.
Look, I’d be happy if they just open source the server code. You don’t need to force the fucks to run the damn software. That’s like the worst idea ever.
it’s also incredibly unlikely to stick, whereas open sourcing server code might happen.
Cool. So then they force the subscription model.
The problem is you want your cake and you want to eat it too.
I want to eat the cake I bought. I don’t want to buy a cake and then have it taken away from me before I’m finished eating it.
I understand you don’t want to deliver cake anymore. That’s fine. You need to open the rest of the box so I can get the rest of my cake out. You don’t need to deliver anymore to me You just need to not take away the cake I already have.
There’s just too many liabilities there.
A lot of these games they have routines to update the entire software OR simply where they can run arbitrary scripts or things like that. Arbitrary code execution would be a huge problem. Even if it wasn’t an automatic thing and you could simply push a message out to people, “hey you need to update this, you know we don’t have the money Ubisoft has, but we’re making some updates anyways because we love y’all! So go download this… And please donate to keep the show going!” Bam. Pwned.
Things like maintaining usernames and passwords being passed off to Independent third parties? The users would fucking revolt at such an idea.
This is one of those things that I get sounds really good in the perfect utopian society where there’s no bad actors. But the reality is people want your cake.
Oh, come on.
Any game with a sufficiently sized community will also have, as part of that community, enough nerds to run private servers if need be.
Hell, WoW is 20 years old and still has to sue to shut down private servers. There’s plenty of ways to make this happen.
Come on what? Give me a target. I’m down.
You’re right that there should be concerns about connecting old games to a random server that can push software updates.
However, I think you’re misunderstanding what the SKG movement is as well as what this legislation is asking for.
It’s not asking for companies to leave the servers running indefinitely. It’s definitely not telling them to just allow a 3rd party to take over the databases with all of the information there.
It’s telling companies to provide information upfront about what consumers can expect when the game servers are officially shut down. It’s telling them to have a plan for shutting the game down.
It provides some options for what those plans could look like:
- Offline mode (and communicate what features will no longer be available)
- Allow private servers
- Refunds
The current version of this bill has an exception for free games and subscription only based games.
A refund makes no sense.
That’s eerily similar to asking for a refund at an arcade machine because you died.
Yea, exactly. This idiotic bill is trying to leverage that which has none, nor should!
The way I see it, a refund is a last resort if they are unable to follow through on the other 2 options.
Using your analogy, asking for a refund at an arcade would be more like asking for a refund for a subscription based online only game. In both of those cases you’re paying to play for a limited amount of time. This bill has an exclusion for that already, so it’s not an issue here.
Think of it this way: Imagine you bought a kitchen appliance (like a refrigerator) that has a screen on the door for creating timers, leaving notes, and checking the weather.
One day, the company says they’re shutting down the servers so that your refrigerator will no longer be able to check the weather, sync notes, etc. However, along with this update the refrigerator will no longer be able to keep food cold.
Wouldn’t you want a refund at that point so that you could buy a new one? Or better yet, maybe we need a law to tell these companies that shutting down their servers shouldn’t affect the core features of the appliance.
This is basically what’s started happening to a large number of games. Instead of just losing access to a few online features, companies are locking us out of the entire game, even if they are mainly a single player game. Just look at what happened to The Crew.
So do you sue MTG because no one wants to play magic anymore?
Same with the pogs people?
The other incredibly shit things people fawn over and then discard like trash?
No dude. You’re trying to sell me some bullshit and I’m not buying it. That’s what you don’t get!
I would accept that if I did pay for such a thing I would be a complete fucking moron and so -no - I wouldn’t be entitled to a refund. And that’s probably expressed in their policy - they don’t issue refunds - and so I don’t know why you would want one after you’ve read their terms and you’ve agreed to buy in their product with the expectation of no refund.
You sound completely fucking insane.
I think the refrigerator example is a much more accurate representation of what’s happening here.
It’s not about whether you can find friends to play with, its about a company remotely disabling something you bought which should be able to work whether it’s connected to the internet or not.
What if a bunch of car manufacturers start requiring an internet connection just to turn on your car (for security/safety reasons). Then after 5 years they shut down those servers and say, “buy a new one”. You’re telling me that, rather than supporting a law to deter the practice, you would rather just avoid buying cars from that company?





