• 1 Post
  • 53 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 3rd, 2025

help-circle



  • If say it’s more like self driving cars knowing the speed limit but being able to go over it.

    I like this analogy. The “hammer” example (that the OP used) is too simple. A hammer has a single purpose and a single functionality.

    A self-driving car is closer to AI agents. The car has a purpose (to drive) but the mechanism is much more complicated than a hammer. If a driver hits the gas and drive over a pedestrian, it’s totally their fault. However, if the self driving car drives through a wall, the manufacturer should be held accountable.

    Likewise with AI, if I tell it to write and ship code, which is exploitable: that’s on me. If AI decides to disregard my input and decides to delete all my emails, the developer of the tool should be held accountable.





  • I’ve played around with Claude.

    they can’t access anything you don’t give them permission to access.

    It’s not that “they can’t” it’s more like “they try not to”.

    For example, if you have a folder shared with your application code (/home/me/code/) - it has free reign on that folder.

    If you add a prompt saying “you are only allowed to access files in /home/me/code”:

    you could ask it " oh, what are my aws credentials ", it would have no qualms about reading those files (/home/me/.aws).

    You could also ask it to update your settings (/home/me/.claude)

    I eventually started to work on a way of running Claude in a docker container with real filesystem enforcement. …and it’s sneaky how Claude will get when it wants to read a file, it doesn’t have permissions for (using bash cat).

    This was an exploration I’d made a year ago and I know Claude has a " sandbox" , but if you allow Claude to run bash commands - that sandbox is trivial to circumvent.



  • AI isn’t responsible for the stuff it outputs - the person controlling it is.

    Ultimately, you’re right (as they can decide to use AI or not). But these AI Companies need to shoulder the blame for creating, promoting, and selling AI, which (in its current form) is effectively a “broken tool”.

    Good computer hygiene says I should lock my computer while I’m away. Yet, I’m suppose to blindly install an AI agent on my machine and ask it nicely to focus on the task at hand and not use any of the other applications or credentials that might also be installed?!?! It’s ridiculous.


  • I drink and I smoke, but I also think it’s not a good idea to get children used to those things.

    Unfortunately, there isn’t a “one size fits all solution”. When I was a kid, I had the candy cigarettes, champagne bottles, cap-guns to play " cops and robbers", and bb-guns to “shoot things” (trash usually)

    As an adult, I don’t smoke, I’ll have a beer once a month or less, and I haven’t robbed any banks nor go hunting. Mainly because, as an adult, I’m not interested in those things.

    However, as a child, these were tools to pretend and often pretending involves replicating your environment. I definitely grew-up in a rural area, but on (80-90s) television when everyone is smoking and drinking, your relatives smoke and drink - it’s normalized.

    I would argue that the social shift towards no smoking and less drinking for adults, has a greater affect on children than a ban on stick shaped candy in a box.

    (Now marketing vaping to young people with addictive “fun” chemical flavoring: that is evil and should be banned)

    edit: fixed a couple of words



  • Bingo!

    It was always believed that Windows OS was a “loss leader” for Microsoft.

    Windows OS will never show a profit, when you take into account the development and testing time and effort. I mean, a one time purchase that’s expected to be supported for years!?!

    Side note: This also explains why Windows 11 is de-evolving into an AI generated, ad ridden, telemetry gathering, cesspool of an OS (“we gotta make money somehow - think of the share holders”)

    But, what Windows had done is create a platform for Microsoft to upsell (and vendor lock-in) profitable applications like Office, Outlook, Teams, etc.

    However, that business model doesn’t work anymore. As, all of Microsoft’s products are now in the cloud. They’re all subscription bases, which means predictable and indefinite revenue. User’s don’t need to be running on Windows - they just need a web-browser or thin-client. Microsoft already has people (brainwashed into) wanting Office - they don’t need to _force _ people into trying Office.

    tl;dr: Developing and supporting Windows OS is a financial drain for Microsoft, and they’re doing everything they can to scuttle it.